An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Introductions
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Introductions
Foreword
"Not of my doing! It all came from Above."
Preface to the Second Edition
The Book's aim: "to carry intelligent
laypeople into the heart of the world's great enduring faiths to the
point where they might see, and even feel, why and how they guide and
motivate the lives of those who live by them."
Acknowledgments
the chief support ... "a wife's help"
Chapter I. Point of Departure
There are God-seekers in every land. Does
one faith carry the lead? We cannot know. All we can do is try to
listen. Such listening, listening for well defined themes defines the
purpose of this book.
A. What this book is not:
1. This book is not a textbook in the
history of religions.
2. Even in the realm of meanings the
book does not attempt to give a rounded view of the religions
considered.
3. This book is not a balanced account
of its subject but of religion at its best. The empowering
theological and metaphysical truths of the world's religions are,
this book is prepared to argue, inspired. Religious
institutions are another story. When religions are sifted for those
truths, a different, cleaner side appears. They become the world's
wisdom traditions.
4. This book is not a book on
comparative religions in the sense of seeking to compare their
worth.
B. What this book is:
1. It is a book that seeks to embrace
the world. We have come to the point in history where we must all
struggle to be a citizen of the world. The only thing that is
unqualifiedly good is extended vision, the enlargement of one's
understanding of the ultimate nature of things.
2. It is a book that takes religion
seriously. Religion is at work on the things that matter most.
Authentic religion has power to inspire life's deepest creative
centers.
3. This book makes a real effort to
communicate. The author has tried not to lose sight of the relevance
this material has for the problems that human beings face today.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter II.
Hinduism
Gandhi wrote: "Such power as I possess for
working in the political field has derived from my experiments in the
spiritual field." In that spiritual field, he went on to say, "truth
is the sovereign principle, and the Bhagavad-Gita is the book par
excellence for knowledge of Truth."
Part One: Hinduism in terms of its practical
import, focusing on practice
A. You can have what you want - The Path of
Desire
1.We begin by wanting pleasure. This
is natural, but it too trivial to satisfy one's total nature.
2.The time comes when the individual's
interest shift to the second major goal of life, which is worldly
success with its three prongs of wealth, fame, and power. This too
is a worthy goal but individuals whose development is not arrested will
move through delighting in success and the senses to the point where
their attractions have been largely outgrown.
3. Hinduism does not say that everyone in
their present life will find the Path of Desire wanting, but at some
point in their reincarnations they will renounce the ego's claim to
finality and transfer all allegiance to a religion of duty. This marks
the first great step in religion.
4. But in the end all worldly rewards prove
insufficient and in some reincarnation we turn to the Path of
Renunciation. This is the moment Hinduism has been waiting for.
B. What People Really Want - The Path of
Renunciation - The Beyond Within:
Hinduism sees the mind's
hidden continents as stretching to infinity. Infinite in being, infinite
in awareness, there is nothing beyond them that remains unknown.
Infinite in joy, too, for there is nothing alien to them to mar their
beatitude.
What the realization of our
total being is like can no more be described than can a sunset to one
born blind: it must be experienced.
1. Four Paths to the Goal. - The
realization of our total being:
Hinduism's specific directions for
actualizing the human potential come under the heading of yoga.
What is distinctive in Hinduism is the
amount of attention is has devoted to identifying basic spiritual
personality types and the disciplines that are most likely to work
four each.
The number of the basic spiritual
personality types, by Hindu count, is four.
The first step on every yoga involves
the cultivation of such habits as non injury, truthfulness, non
stealing, self control, contentment, self discipline, and a
compelling desire to reach the goal.
The four Paths are:
a. The Way to God through
Knowledge.
Jnana yoga, intended
for spiritual aspirants who have a strong reflected bent, is
the path to oneness with the Godhead through knowledge. Such
knowledge has nothing to do with factual information; it is
not encyclopedic. It is, rather, an intuitive discernment
that transforms, turning the knower eventually into that
which she knows.
The yoga of knowledge is said to be the shortest
path to divine realization. It is also the steepest.
Requiring as it does a rare combination of rationality and
spirituality, it is for a select few.
b. The Way to God through Love.
Bhakti yoga has
countless followers, being, indeed, the most popular of the
four.
The basic principles of bhakti yoga are richly
exemplified in Christianity. Indeed, from the Hindu Point of
view, Christianity is one great brilliantly lit bhakti
highway toward God.
c. The Way to God through Work.
The third path toward God,
intended for persons of active bent is karma yoga,
the path to God through work.
To such people Hinduism's says, you don't have
to retire to a cloister to realize God. You can find God in
the world of everyday affairs as readily as anywhere. Throw
yourself into your work with everything you have; but do so
wisely, in a way that will bring the highest rewards, not
just trivia.
d. The Way to God through
Psychophysical Exercises.
Raja yoga is designed
for people who are of scientific bent. It is the way to god
through psychophysical experiments.
Hinduism encourages people to
test all four yogas and combined them as best suits their
needs.
2. The Stages of Life.
The preceding sections traced
Hinduism's insistence that differences in human nature call for a
variety of paths toward life's fulfillment. Not only do individuals
differ from one another
each individual moves through different stages, each of which calls
for its own appropriate conduct. The stages are:
a. That of the student
b. Beginning with marriage, that of
the householder
c. Eventually decline leads to the
third stage - retirement -the time to leave family and home and
plunge into the forest solitudes to launch a program of
self-discovery.
d. Beyond retirement, the final
stage wherein the goal is actually reached, the state of the
sannyasin where "one neither hates nor loves anything"
3. The Stations of Life. - The caste
system
What is called for here is recognition
that with respect to the ways they can best contribute to society
and develop their own potentialities, people fall into four groups;
at the top being the brahmins (intellectual and spiritual
leaders) down to shudras (followers or servants).
Caste has decayed and is as offensive
as any other corrupted corpse.
Part Two: Hinduism focusing on theory, the
principal philosophical concepts that rib the Hindu religion
A. "Thou Before Whom All Words Recoil." -
The concept of God
Concepts of God contain so much alloy to
begin with that two contradictory ones may be true, each from a
different angle, as both wave and particles may be equally accurate
heuristic devices for describing the nature of light.
On the whole India has been content to
encourage the devotee of Brahman as either personal or
transpersonal, depending on which carries the most exalted meaning for
the mind in question.
B. Coming of Age in the Universe. -
Reincarnation
The process by which an individual soul (jiva)
passes through a sequence of bodies is known as reincarnation or
transmigration of the soul - Sanskrit samsara, a word that
signifies endless passage through cycles of life, death, and rebirth.
On the subhuman level the passage is
through a series of increasingly complex bodies until at last a human
one is attained.
With the soul's graduation into a human
body, this automatic escalator-like mode of ascent comes to an end. the
soul has reached self-consciousness, and with this estate come freedom,
responsibility, and effort.
Each thought and deed delivers an unseen
chisel blow that sculpts one's destiny. Everybody gets exactly what is
deserved.
Never during its pilgrimage is the human
spirit completely adrift and alone. From start to finish its nucleus is
the Atman, the God within, exerting pressure to "out" like a
jack-in-the-box. Never seen but is the Witness; never heard but is
the Hearer; never thought but is the Thinker; never known but is the
Knower.
In the end it is God's radiating warmth
that melts the soul's icecap, turning it into a pure capacity for God.
What happens then? Some say the individual
soul passes into complete identification with God and loses every trace
of its former separateness. Other that some slight differentiation
between the soul and God will still remain - a thin line upon the ocean
that provides nevertheless a remnant of personal identity that some
consider indispensable for the beatific vision.
C. The World — Welcome and Farewell.
What kind of world do we have? Hinduism
answers:
1. A multitude of worlds that includes
innumerable galaxies horizontally, innumerable tiers vertically,
innumerable cycles temporally.
2.
A moral world in which the law of karma is never suspended.
3. A middling world that will never replace
paradise as the spirits destination.
4.
A world that is maya, deceptively tricky in passing off
its multiplicity, materiality, and dualities as ultimate when they are
actually provisional.
5. A
training ground on which people can develop their highest capacities.
6. A
world that is lila, the play of the divine in its cosmic dance -
untiring, unending, resistless, yet ultimately beneficent with a grace
born of infinite vitality.
D. Many Paths to the Same Summit.
That Hinduism has shared her land for
centuries with Jains, Buddhists, Parsees, Muslims, Sikhs, and Christians
may help explain the final idea that comes out more clearly through her
than through the other great religions; namely, her conviction that the
various major religions are alternate paths to the same goal.
To claim salvation as the monopoly of any
one religion is like claiming that God can be found in this room but not
the next, in this attire but not another.
In practice India's sects have often been
fanatically intolerant, but in principle most have been open.
Part Three: Appendix on Sikhism.
Hindus are inclined to regard Sikhs as somewhat
wayward members of their own extended family. Sikhs see their faith as
having issued from an original divine revelation that inaugurated a new
religion.
The revelation affirms the ultimacy of a
supreme and formless God who is beyond human conceiving. It rejects the
notion of divine incarnations, caste distinctions, images as aids to
worship, and the sanctity of the Vedas. The Sikh revelations endorse the
doctrine of reincarnation.
Sikhs seek salvation through union with God by
realizing, through love, the Person of God, who dwells in depths of their
own being. Union with God is the ultimate goal. Apart from God life has no
meaning; it is separation from God that causes human suffering.
World renunciation does not figure in
this faith. The Sikhs have no tradition of renunciation, asceticism,
celibacy, or mendicancy.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter III. Buddhism
Part One: Buddha the Man
The Man Who Woke Up. - The Silent Sage.
Born around 563 B.C.
Heir to a throne, he deserted it at
age twenty-nine.
Sensing that that a breakthrough
was near, he seated himself one epoch-making evening vowing not
to arise until enlightenment was his. At morning his mind
pierced at last the bubble of the universe and shattered it to
naught, only, wonder of wonders, to find it miraculously
restored with effulgence of true being.
Nearly half a century followed,
during which the Buddha trudged the dusty paths of India
preaching his ego-shattering, life-redeeming message.
Part Two: Buddhism the Religion
A. The Rebel Saint.
Buddhism drew its lifeblood from
Hinduism, but against its prevailing corruptions Buddhism
recoiled like a whiplash and hit back - hard.
Buddha preached a religion devoid
of authority, devoid of ritual, a religion that skirted
speculation, devoid of tradition, a religion of intense
self-effort, devoid of supernatural.
Original Buddhism can be
characterized in the following terms:
empirical - experience was the
final test of truth
scientific - quality of lived
experience its final test
pragmatic - concerned with
problem solving
therapeutic - "One thing I
teach, suffering and the end of suffering."
psychological - begins with the
human lot, its problems, and the dynamics of coping with
them
egalitarian - women as capable
of enlightenment as men; rejected the caste system's
assumption that aptitudes were hereditary
directed to individuals -
each should proceed toward enlightenment through confronting
his or her individual situation and predicaments
B. The Four Noble Truths. - the
postulates from which the rest of his teachings logically derive
1. Life is suffering, is
dislocated, something has gone wrong.
2. The cause - all forms of
selfishness
Instead of linking our faith
and love and destiny to the whole, we persist in strapping
to puny burros of our separate selves, which are certain to
stumble and give out eventually.
3. Since the cause of life's
dislocation is selfish craving, its cure lies in the overcoming
of such craving.
4. The Forth Noble Truth prescribes
how the cure can be accomplished.
The way out of our captivity is
through the Eightfold Path.
C. The Eightfold Path. - it is a
treatment by training - by right association - We should associate
with Truthwinners, converse with them, serve them, observe their
ways, and imbibe by osmosis their spirit of love and compassion.
1. Right Views - The first step
summons us to make up our minds as to what life's problem
basically is.
2. Right Intent - The second
advises us to make up our hearts as to what we really want.
3. Right Speech
first become aware of our
speech
second move toward charity
4. Right Conduct
understand one's actions
change to the direction of
selflessness and charity
do not drink intoxicants
5. Right Livelihood - For the lay
person, Buddhism calls for engaging in occupations that promote
life instead of destroying it.
6. Right Effort - A low level of
volition, a mere wish not accompanied by effort or action to
obtain it - won't do.
7. Right Mindfulness
This seventh step summons the
seeker to steady awareness of every action that is taken,
and every content that turns up in one's stream of
consciousness.
Special times should be
allotted for undistracted introspection.
8. Right Concentration
This involves substantially the
techniques of Hinduism's raja yoga and leads to
substantially the same goal.
The final climactic state is
the state in which the human mind is completely absorbed in
God.
D. Basic Buddhist Concepts. -
Certain key notions in the Buddha's outlook
1. nirvana - Life's goal -
boundless life
2. anatta - The human self
has no soul
3. karma - One's acts
considered as fixing one's lot in the future existence
4. anicca - impermanence,
everything finite is transitory
5. Arhat -
a Buddhist who has reached the stage
of enlightenment
Do human beings survive bodily
death? - his answer is equivocal
E. Big Raft and Little. - Two main
Paths in Buddhism
Buddhism divided over three
questions: are people independent or interdependent, is the
universe friendly or hostile toward creatures, and what is the
best part of the human self, its head or its heart.
One group says "Be lamps unto your
selves, work out your salvation with diligence"
For the other group, human beings
are more social than individual, and love is the greatest thing
in the world.
The division into the two main
paths is schematized as follows:
THERAVADA |
MAHAYANA |
Human beings are emancipated by self-effort, with
out supernatural aid. |
Human aspirations are supported by
divine powers and the grace they bestow. |
Key virtue: wisdom |
Key virtue: compassion |
Attainment requires constant commitment,
and is primarily for monks and nuns. |
Religious practice is
relevant to life in the world, and therefore to
laypeople. |
Ideal: the Arhat who remains in nirvana
after death |
Ideal: the boddhisattva |
Buddha a saint, supreme teacher, and inspirer. |
Buddha a savior |
Minimizes metaphysics |
Elaborates metaphysics |
Minimizes ritual |
Emphasizes ritual |
Practice centers on meditation |
Includes petitionary prayer |
After Buddhism split into Thervada and Mahayana, Theravada
continued as a fairly unified tradition, whereas Mahayana
divided into a number of denominations or schools. The two with
the most influence in western society, Zen Buddhism and Tibetan
Buddhism are discussed next.
F. The Secret of the Flower. - Zen
Buddhism
Buddhism that Taoism profoundly
influenced, Ch'an (Zen in Japanese)
It makes breaking the language
barrier its central concern.
Strains by every means to blast
their novices out of solutions that are only verbal.
Zen masters are determined that
their students attain the experience itself, not allow talk to
take its place.
By paradox and non sequitur Zen
provokes, excites, exasperates, and eventually exhausts the mind
until until it sees that thinking is never more than thinking about, or feeling more than feeling
for.
It counts on a flash of sudden
insight to bridge the gap between secondhand and firsthand life.
Zen's object is to infuse the
temporal with the eternal.
A condition in which life seems
distinctly good
Also comes an objective outlook
on one's relation to others.
The life of Zen does not draw
one away from the world; it turns one to the world.
An attitude of generalized
agreeableness
Even the dichotomy between life
and death disappears.
G. The Diamond Thunderbolt. - Tibetan
Buddhism
The Tibetans say that their
religion is nowise distinctive in its goal. What distinguishes
their practice is that it enables one to reach nervana in
a single lifetime. They say that the speed-up is effected
by utilizing all the energies latent in the human make-up ,
those of the body emphatically included, and impressing them all into the service of the spiritual quest.
The energy that interests the West
most is sex, but the physical energies they most regularly work
with are the ones that are involved with speech, vision, and
gestures.
Tibetan Buddhism distinctiveness
also includes a unique institution - The Dalai Lama.
The Dalai Lama is a receiving
station toward which the compassion-principle of Buddhism in all
its cosmic amplitude is continuously channeled, to radiate
thence to the Tibetan people most directly, but by extension to
all sentient beings.
H. The Image of the Crossing.
Do the various Paths of Buddhism
deserve to be considered aspects of a single religion?
Yes, in two ways:
(1.) They all revere a single
founder from whom they claim their teachings derive.
(2.) All can be subsumed under a
single metaphor - the image of the crossing.
Buddhism is a voyage across
life's river, a transport from the common-sense shore of
ignorance, grasping, and death, to the further bank of
wisdom and enlightenment.
Before the river was crossed
the two shores, human and divine, had to appear distinct
from each other, different as life and death, as day and
night. But once the crossing has been made, no dichotomy
remains. The realm of the gods is not a distinct place. It
is where the traveler stands; and if that stance happens to
be in this world, the world itself is transmuted.
Part Three: The Confluence of Buddhism and Hinduism in
India.
Today Buddhists abound in every Asian
land except India, the land of its birth. The deeper fact is that in India Buddhism was not so much defeated
by Hinduism as accommodated within it. Its contributions, accepted by Hindus in principle if not always
practice, included its renewed emphasis on kindness to all living
things, on non-killing of animals, on the elimination of caste
barriers in matters religious and their reduction in matters social,
and its strong ethical emphasis generally.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter IV. Confucianism
Part One: The First Teacher.
Born around 551 B.C.
Prompted as if by call - "At fifty I
perceived the divine mission" - he gave his next thirteen years, with
many a backward look and resisting footsteps, to "the long trek," in
which he wandered from state to state proffering unsolicited advice to
rulers on how to improve their governing and seeking a real opportunity
to put his ideas into practice. The opportunity never came.
Only a small band of faithful disciples
stood by him through rebuff, discouragement, and near starvation.
He spent his last five years quietly
teaching and editing the classics of China's past. In 479 B.C., at the
age of seventy-two he died.
With hid death began his glorification.
Within a few generations he was regarded throughout China as "the mentor
and model of ten thousand generations."
Part Two: The Problem Confucius Faced.
By Confucius' time interminable warfare had
degenerated from chivalry toward the unrestrained horror of the Period
of the Warring States.
The old mortar that had held society
together was chipping and flaking. Unreflective solidarity was a thing
of the past.
Part Three: Rival Answers.
As the alternative to tradition, the United
States has proposed reason. Educate citizens and inform them, and they
can be counted on to behave sensibly - this is the
Jeffersonian-Enlightenment faith on which the United States was founded.
It has not been fulfilled. Until recently the world's leader in
education, the United States leads likewise in crime, delinquency, and
divorce.
One option that ancient China proposed was
put forward by the Realists. What do you do when people don't behave?
Hit them. The Realists' philosophy of social order proceeded by way of
an elaborate mechanism of "penalties and rewards".
A social philosophy as different from the
Realists' as fire from ice existed alongside it in Confucius' China.
Known as Mohism, it proposed as the solution to China's social problem
not force but love - universal love. One should "feel toward all people
under heaven exactly as one feels toward one's own people, and regard
other states exactly as one regards one's own state."
Neither of these rival answers to the
problem of social cohesion impressed Confucius. He rejected the
Realists' answer of force because it was clumsy and external. As for the
Mohists' reliance on love, Confucius agreed with the Realists in
dismissing it as utopian. The West's current approach to the social
problem - through the cultivation of reason - probably did not occur to
Confucius. If it had he would have dismissed it as not thought through.
Part Four: Confucius' Answer.- Deliberate
Tradition
Confucius was all but obsessed with
tradition, he saw it as the chief shaper of inclinations and attitudes.
Spontaneous tradition- tradition that had
emerged without conscious intent had ruled villages without dissent but
could no longer be counted on.
The most appropriate solution must be
continuous with the past and at the same time must take a clear-eyed
account of developments that rendered the old answer unworkable.
The shift from spontaneous to deliberate
tradition requires a power of suggestion that can prompt society's
members to behave socially even when the law is not looking. The
technique pivots around "patterns of prestige."
The interminable anecdotes and maxims of
Confucius' Analects were designed to create the prototype of what
the Chinese hoped the Chinese character would become.
A. The Content of Deliberate Tradition.
Deliberate
tradition requires attention first to maintain its force and
second attention to the content of that education. The
character of the social life Confucius intended to engender can
be gathered under five key terms:
1. Jen.-
The ideal relationship that
should pertain between people
Involves simultaneously a
feeling of humanity toward others and respect for oneself
Expressed in courtesy,
unselfishness, and empathy
"Do not do unto others what you
would not want others to do unto you."
2. Chun tzu - The mature
person
Opposite of a petty person, a
mean person, a small-spirited person
Armed with self-respect that
generates respect for others
Speech free of coarseness and
vulgarity
Person who is entirely real
3. Li - Has two meanings:
a. Propriety, the way things
should be done - Confucius taught this mainly by:
the Rectification of
Names - the creation of a language in which key
nouns carry the meaning they should carry if life is to
be well ordered.
the Doctrine of the Mean
- the way that is "constantly in the middle" between
unworkable extremes
the Five constant
Relationships - those between parent and child,
husband and wife, elder and junior sibling, elder friend
and junior friend, and ruler and subject -It is vital to
the health of society that these key relationships be
rightly constituted.
the Family - "The
duty of children to their parents is the fountain from
which all virtues spring.
Age - Confucius saw
age as deserving veneration by reason of its intrinsic
worth.
b. Ritual - When right behavior
is detailed to Confucian lengths, the individual's entire
life becomes stylized in a sacred dance, leaving little need
for improvisation.
4. Te - the power by which
men are ruled
No state, Confucius was
convinced, can constrain all its citizens all the time, nor
even any large fraction of them a large part of the time. It
must rely on acceptance of its will, an appreciable
confidence in what it is doing.
This spontaneous consent arises
only when people sense their leaders to be people of
capacity, sincerely devoted to the common good and possessed
of the kind of character that compels respect.
For the process to work,
however, rulers must have no personal ambition. Only those
are worthy to govern who would rather be excused.
5. Wen -
The arts of peace as contrasted to the arts of war
Music, art, poetry, the sum of
culture in its aesthetic and spiritual mode
Ultimately, victory goes to the
state that develops the highest wen, the most exalted
culture - the state that has the finest art, the noblest
philosophy, the grandest poetry.
B. The Confucian Project. - how life
would appear to a Chinese set within it
As a never-ending project of
self-cultivation toward the end of becoming more fully human
Apart from human relationships
there is no self. The self is a center of relationships. It is
constructed through its interactions with others and is defined
by the sum of its social roles.
A notion very different from
Western individualism - the human self as a node, not an entity.
Ascent means becoming a fully
realized human being through expanding one's sympathy and
empathy indefinitely.
The expansion is in concentric
circles that begins with oneself and spreads from there to
include successively one's family, one's face-to-face community,
one's nation, and finally all humanity.
In shifting the center of one's
empathic concern from oneself to one's family one transcends
selfishness. The move from family to community transcends
nepotism. The move from community to nation overcomes
parochialism, and the move to all humanity counters chauvinistic
nationalism.
Inside and outside work together in
the Confucian scheme.
Always the practice field is the
Five Constant Relationships. Mastering a role in one of the five
sheds light on the other roles. To improve as a parent throws
light on what being a good child (of one's own parents) entails.
The nuances of the other roles likewise illuminate one another.
C. Ethics or Religion?
If religion is taken in its widest
sense, as a way of life woven around a people's ultimate
concerns, Confucianism clearly qualifies. Even if religion is
taken in a narrower sense, as a concern to align humanity with
the transcendental ground of its existence,
Confucianism is still a religion.
To understand the total dimension
of Confucianism as a religion it is important to see Confucius
shifting his people's attention from Heaven to Earth without
dropping Heaven from the picture entirely.
The Confucian project of becoming
fully human involves transcending, sequentially, egoism,
nepotism, parochialism. ethnocentrism, and chauvinistic
nationalism and (we now add) isolating self-sufficient humanism.
D. Impact on China.
For over two thousand years
Confucius' teachings have profoundly affected a quarter of the
population of this globe. Confucian values merged with the
generic values of the Chinese people to the point where it is
difficult to separate the two.
The features mentioned below pretty
much blanket East Asia as a whole, for Japan, Korea, and much of
Southeast Asia deliberately imported Confucian ethic.
1. Confucius' social emphasis
produced, in the Chinese, a conspicuous social effectiveness - a
capacity to get things done in a large scale when need arose.
2. Unique among the world's
civilizations, China syncretized her religions. Traditionally,
every Chinese was Confucian in ethics and public life, Taoist in
private life and hygiene, and Buddhist at the time of death,
with a healthy dash of shamanistic folk religion thrown in along
the way.
3. The importance of the family in
China - Strong family bonds can smother, but they also bring
benefits, and these work for East Asians right down to the
present.
4. East Asian respect for age
borders on veneration.
5. Confucius' Doctrine of the Mean
continues to this day in the Chinese preference for negotiation,
mediation, and the
"middle man" as against resorting to rigid, impersonal statutes.
6. China honors Confucius'
conviction that learning and the arts are not mere veneer but
are powers that transform societies and the human heart.
7. The East Asian economic miracle
of the last forty years, shaped by the Confucian ethic,
constitutes the dynamic center of economic growth in the latter
twentieth century.
8. The courtesy for which Orientals
have been famous echoes the Confucian spirit.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter V. Taoism
No
civilization is monochrome. In China the classical tones of Confucianism have
been balanced by the spiritual shades of Buddhism but also by the romantic hues
of Taoism
Part One: The Old Master. - Lao Tzu
Taoism, according to tradition originated
with a man named Lao Tzu.
A shadowy figure, born about 604 B. C.
Before his retirement from society, he left
a slim volume of five thousand characters titled Tao Te Ching, or
The Way and Its Power.
A testament to humanity's at home-ness in
the universe, it can be read in half an hour or a lifetime, and remains
to this day the basic text of Taoist thought.
He didn't preach he didn't organize or
promote, he wrote a few pages on request, rode off on a water buffalo,
and that was it as far as he was concerned.
Part Two: The Religion He Founded - Taoism
A. The Three Meanings of Tao. -
Literally, this word means path or way.
1. The way of ultimate reality -
This Tao cannot be perceived or even clearly conceived, for
it is too vast for human rationality to fathom.
2. It is also immanent. - In this
secondary sense it is the way of the universe, the norm, the
rhythm, the driving power in all nature, the ordering principle
behind all life.
3. In its third sense Tao refers to the
way of human life when it meshes with the Tao of the universe
as just described. Most of what follows in this chapter will detail
what the Taoists propose that this way of life should be.
First, however, it is necessary to
point out that there have been in China not one but three Taoisms.
B. Three Approaches to Power and the Taoisms That
Follow. - Tao Te Ching, the title of Taoism's basic text, has been
translated The Way and its Power. Just as the first term
Way can be taken in three senses, so can the second term Power.
Corresponding to the three ways
Te or power and be approached,
there have arisen in China three species of Taoism so dissimilar that
initially they seem to have no more in common than homonyms like
blew/blue or sun/son, that sound alike but have different meanings. We
shall find that this is not the case.
All were engaged in vitalizing programs
that were intended to facilitate Tao's power, its te, as it flows
through human beings.
1. Efficient Power: Philosophical Taoism.
Philosophical Taoists try to
conserve their te by expanding it efficiently, whereas
the other two "vitality" Taoists work to increase its
supply.
It is essentially an attitude
toward life, it is the most "exportable" Taoism of the three,
the one that has the most to say to the world at large.
2. Augmented Power: Taoist Hygiene and Yoga.
These Taoists want to go beyond
conserving to increasing the quota of the Tao they had to work
with.
They worked with three things:
matter, movement, and their minds.
They tried eating virtually
everything to see if ch'i could be augmented
nutritionally.
They sought to draw ch'i from the
atmosphere by breathing exercises.
They used programs of bodily
movement such as t'ai chi chuan, which gathers
calisthenics, dance, meditation, yin/yang philosophy,
martial arts, and acupuncture into synthesis that was designed
to draw ch'i from the cosmos and dislodge blocks to its
internal flow.
Taoist meditation, (the physical
postures and concentration techniques are reminiscent of Indian
reja yoga),
was designed to reach realization with which comes truth, joy,
and power.
The Taoist yogis recognized that
they could not hope for much understanding from the masses, and
they made no attempt to publicize their position.
3. Vicarious Power: Religious Taoism.
Reflection and health programs take
time, and the average Chinese lacked that commodity. Yet they
too needed help.
Taoists responded to such problems.
Using the unchanging landscape of Chinese folk religion,
Religious Taoism institutionalized such activities.
Popular, Religious Taoism is a
murky affair. Much of it looks - from the outside, we must
always keep in mind - like crude superstition; but we must
remember that we have little idea what energy is, how it
proceeds, or the means by which (and extent to which) it can be
augmented.
It was under the rubric of magic as
traditionally conceived that the Taoist church - dividing the
territory with freelance wizards, exorcists, and shamans -
devised way to harness higher powers for humane ends.
C. The Mingling of the Powers.
In the interest of clarity, the lines
between the above three divisions have been drawn too sharply. No
solid walls separate them; the three are better regarded as currents
in a common river.
Where these three things come together
there is a "school", and in China the school this chapter describes
is Taoism.
D. Creative Quietude. - The object of
Philosophical Taoism
The object of Philosophical Taoism is
to align one's daily life to the Tao, to ride its boundless
tide and delight in its flow.
The basic way to do this is to perfect
a life of wu wei.
Creative quietude combines within a
single individual two seemingly incompatible conditions - supreme
activity and supreme relaxation. This happens when our private egos
and conscious efforts yield to a power not their own.
Effectiveness of this order obviously
requires an extraordinary skill.
Clarity can come to the inner eye only
insofar as life attains a quiet that equals that of a deep and
silent pool.
E. Other Taoist Values.
The Taoists rejected all forms of
self-assertiveness and competition.
People should avoid being strident and
aggressive not only toward other people but also toward nature.
This Taoist approach to nature deeply
affected Chinese art.
Pomp and extravagance were regarded as
silly.
It was this preference for naturalness
and simplicity that most separated the Taoist from the Confucian.
All formalism, show and ceremony left
them cold. What could be hoped for from punctiliousness or the
meticulous observance of propriety?
Another feature of Taoism is its notion
of the relativity of al values and, as its correlative, the identity
of opposites. Here Taoism tied in with the traditional Chinese yin/yang symbol.
This polarity sums up all life's basic
oppositions: good/evil, active/passive, positive/negative/negative,
light/dark, summer/winter, male/female. But though the halves are in
tension, they are not flatly opposed; they complement and balance
each other. Each invades the other's hemisphere and takes up its
abode in the deepest recess of its partner's domain. In the end both
find themselves resolved by the circle that surrounds them.
In the Taoist perspective even good and
evil are not head-on opposites.
If this all sounds very much like Zen,
it should; for Buddhism processed through Taoism became Zen.
That in China the scholar ranked at the
top of the social scale may have been Confucius' doing, but Taoism
is fully as responsible for placing the soldier at the bottom. "The
way for a vital person to go is not the way of a soldier."
Part Three - Conclusion.
Circling around each other like yin and
yang themselves, Taoism and Confucianism represent the two indigenous
poles of the Chinese character. Confucius represents the classical, Lao
Tzu the romantic. Confucius stresses social responsibility, Lao Tzu
praises spontaneity and naturalness. Confucius' focus is on the
human, Lau Tzu's on what transcends the human.
Confucius roams within society, Lao Tzu
wanders beyond. Something in life reaches out in each of these
directions, and Chinese civilization would certainly have been poorer if
either had not appeared.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter VI. Islam
Named
after the attribute it seeks to cultivate, life's total surrender to God
Part One: Background.
If asked how their religion came into
being, the Muslims' answer is Islam begins not with Muhammad in the
sixth-century Arabia, but with God. "In the beginning God ....." the
book of Genesis tells us. The Koran agrees.
Like the Jews, the Arabs consider
themselves a Semitic people. The descendants of Shem led to Abraham.
Abraham married Sarah. Sarah had no son, so Abraham, wanting to continue
his line, took Hagar for his second wife. Hagar bore him a son, Ishmael,
whereupon Sarah conceived and likewise had a son, named Isaac.
Here we come to the first divergence
between the koranic and biblical accounts. According to the Koran,
Ishmael went to the place where Mecca was to rise. His descendents,
flourishing in Arabia, become Muslims; whereas those of Isaac, who
remained in Palestine, were Hebrews and became Jews.
Part Two: The Religion
A. The Seal of the Prophets. -
Muhammad
Following Ismael's line in Arabia,
we come in the latter half of the sixth century A.D. to Muhammad,
the prophet through whom Islam reached its definitive form.
Muslims believe there had been
authentic prophets of God before him, but he was their culmination;
hence he is called "The Seal of the Prophets." No valid prophets
will follow him.
He was born approximately A.D. 570.
Peering
into the mysteries of good and evil, " great fiery heart, seething,
simmering like a great furnace of thought," was reaching out for
God.
The desert jinn were irrelevant to this
quest, but one deity was not. Named Allah, He was what his name
litterally claimed: He was the God, One and only, One without rival.
Around 610, this prophet received his
commission. It was the same command that had fallen earlier on
Abraham, Moses, Samuel, Isaiah, and Jesus. There came to him an
angel in the form of a man. The angel said to his: "Proclaim!"
Muhammad's life was no more his own.
From that time forth it was given to God and to humanity, preaching
with unswerving purpose in face of relentless persecution, insult,
and outrage, the words that God was to transmit for twenty-three
years. These words became the Koran.
Muhammad claimed only one miracle, that
of the Koran itself. (The content of the revelation, the Koran will
be describe in section C, below.)
At first he made few converts, by the
end of a decade, only several hundred families were acclaiming him
as God's authentic spokesman.
B. The Migration That Led to Victory.
Muhammad was suddenly waited on by a
delegation of the leading citizens of Yathrib, a city 280 miles to
Mecca's north. They wished him to move his ministry to their city.
Muhammad received a sign from God to
accept the charge. The year was 622. The migration, known in Arabic
as the Hijra, is regarded by Muslims as the turning point in
world history. Yathrib soon came to be known as Medina, "the city."
Muhammad died in A.D. 632 with
virtually all of Arabia under his control and laid the basis of an
empire that was soon to embrace within its far-flung boundaries the
fairest provinces of the then civilized world.
C. The Standing Miracle. - the Koran
The blend of admiration, respect, and
affection that the Muslim feels for Muhammad is an impressive fact
of history. Even so, they never mistake him for the earthly center
of their faith. That place is reserved for the bible of Islam, the
Koran.
So great was Muhammad's regard for its
contents that he considered it the only major miracle God worked
through him - God's "standing miracle," as he called it.
The words of the Koran came to Muhammad
in manageable segments over twenty-three years through voices that
seemed at first to vary and sometimes sounded like "reverberating
bells," but which gradually condensed into a single voice that
identified itself as Gabriel's.
The Koran continues the Old and New
Testament, God's earlier revelations, and presents itself as their
culmination: "We made a covenant of old with the Children of Israel
(and) you have nothing of guidance until you observe the Torah and
the Gospel". This entitles Jews and Christians to be included with
Muslims as "People of the Book."
However the Koran claims final and
infallible revelation of God's will. "This is the Scripture whereof
there is no doubt."
In the Koran God speaks in the first
person. Allah describes himself and makes known his laws. The Muslim
is therefore inclined to consider each individual sentence of the
Holy Book as a separate revelation and to experience of the words
themselves, even their sounds, as a means of grace. "It is not about
the truth; it is the truth."
By contrast the Jewish and Christian
Bibles seem more distant from God for placing religious meaning in
reports of events instead of God's direct pronouncements.
D. Teachings of the Koran
1. Basic Theological Concepts.- the
basic theological concepts of Islam are virtually identical with
those of Judaism and Christianity, its forerunners. The four that
are most important are:
a. God
The Koran's innovation was to
remove idols from the religious scene and focus the divine
in a single God for everyone. Judaism removed idols but its
teachings were confined to the people of Israel. Christians,
for their part, compromised their monotheism by deifying
Christ.
The Koran depicts God's nature
as awesome, of infinite power, of great mercy.
b. Creation
The world is presented as
created by a deliberate act of Allah's will; as the
handiwork of a perfect God, the material world must likewise
be good.
c. The Human Self - Foremost among
God's creations
As koranically defined, this
creation is
soundly constituted. The closest Islam comes to the
Christian doctrine of original sin is in its concept of ghaflah, or forgetting. People do forget their divine
origin, and this mistake needs repeatedly to be corrected.
With life acknowledged as a
gift from its Creator comes two obligations:
Gratitude for the life that
has been received
Surrender or commitment in
which nothing is withheld from the Divine
Two more features of the human
self are:
Its individuality - its
uniqueness and the responsibility that devolves on it
alone; never is its distinctness more acutely sensed
than on the Day of Judgment.
The issue of the soul's
freedom - Whoever gets to himself a sin, gets it solely
on his own responsibility.
d. The Day of Judgment
It is the
tearing away of all illusions of security that characterizes the
doctrine of the Last Judgment and its anticipation in the Koran.
Depending on how it fares in its Reckoning, the soul will repair
to either the heavens or the hells.
God, Creation, the Human Self, and
the Day of Judgment - these are the chief theological pegs on
which the Koran's teachings hang. In spite of their importance,
however, the Koran is "a book which emphasizes deed rather than
idea". The next two sections turn to these deeds.
2. The Five Pillars.- The principles
that regulate the private life of Muslims in their dealings with
God.
a. Islam's creed, or confession of
faith known as the Shahadah. "There is no god but God,
and Muhammad is His Prophet."
b. The canonical prayer, in which
the Koran adjures the faithful to "be constant".
Muslims are admonished to
be constant in prayer to keep their lives in perspective.
There are five stipulated prayer times: on arising, when the
sun reaches its zenith, its mid-decline, sunset, and before
retiring.
As for prayer's content, its
standard themes are praise, gratitude, and supplication.
c. The third pillar of Islam is
charity. Those who have much should help lift the burden of
those who are less fortunate.
d. The fourth pillar of Islam is
the observance of Ramadan, a month of fasting.
e. Islam's fifth pillar is
pilgrimage. Once during his or her lifetime every Muslim who is
physically and economically in a position to do so is expected
to journey to Mecca, where God's climactic revelation was first
disclosed.
The Five Pillars of Islam consist
of things Muslims do to keep the house of Islam erect. There are
also things they should not do. Gambling, thieving, lying,
eating pork, drinking intoxicants, and being sexually
promiscuous are some of these.
3. Social Teachings.
Before Muhammad there was virtually
no restraint on internal violence. Glaring inequities in wealth
and possession were accepted as the natural order of things.
women were regarded more as possessions than as human beings.
Drunkenness and large-scale gambling was widespread. Thanks to
Islamic law, within a half-century there was effected a
remarkable change in the moral climate on all of these counts.
Islamic law is of enormous scope.
Its provisions are here summarized in four areas of collective
life:
a. Economics
Society's health requires that
material goods be widely and appropriately distributed.
These are the basic principles of Islamic economics. It
simply insists that acquisitiveness and competition be
balanced by fair play and by compassion for the poor.
b. The Status of Women - The
koranic reforms improved woman's status incalculably.
c. Race Relations - Islam stresses
racial equality and has achieved a remarkable degree of
interracial coexistence.
d. The Use of Force
Far from requiring the Muslim
to turn himself into a doormat for the ruthless, the Koran
allows punishment of wonton wrongdoers to the full extent of
the injury they impart. The Koran does not counsel turning
the other cheek, or pacifism.
Muhammad incorporated into his
charter for Medina the principle of religious toleration.
Islam's record on the use of force is no darker than that of
Christianity.
Muslims deny that the blots in
their record should be charged against their religion whose
presiding ideal they affirm in their standard greeting, as-salami 'alaykum ("Peace be upon you").
Part Three: Sufism.
Islam is not monolithic, like every
religious tradition it divides. Its main historical division is between
the mainstream Sunnis and the Shi'ites which turns on an in-house
dispute. Here we take up instead a division that has universal
overtones. It is the vertical division between the mystics of
Islam, called Sufis and the remaining majority of the faith, who are
equally good Muslims but are not mystics.
It stands to reason that not many Muslims
will have the time, it the inclination, to do more than keep up with the
Devine Law that orders their lives. Their fidelity is not in vain; in
the end their reward will be as great as the Sufis'. But the Sufis were
impatient for their reward, if we may put the matter thus. They wanted
to encounter God directly in this very lifetime. Now.
This called for special methods. They
developed three overlapping but distinguishing routes, the mysticisms of
love, of ecstasy, and of intuition.
A. The mysticism of love - Sufi love poetry
is world famous. Persian poets in particular dwelt on the pangs of
separation to deepen their love of God and thereby draw close to him.
B. The mysticism of ecstasy
The approach to the divine presence
that turns on experiences that differ, not just in degree but in
kind, from usual ones
The content of what ecstatic Sufis
experience engrosses them so completely that their states become
trancelike because of their total abstraction from self.
Deliberate inducement of such states
required practice.
C. The mysticism of intuition
Love mysticism yields "heart
knowledge", and ecstasy "visual or visionary knowledge" because
extraterrestrial realities are seen.
Intuitive mysticism brings "mental
knowledge" obtained through an organ of discernment called "the eye
of the heart."
To the eye of the heart, the world is
God-in-disguise, God veiled.
The principal method the Sufis employed
for penetrating the disguise is symbolism. In using visible objects
to speak of invisible things, symbolism is the language of religion
generally; it is to religion what numbers are to science.
Symbolism, though powerful, works
somewhat abstractly, so the Sufis supplement it with dhikr
(to remember), the practice of remembering Allah through repeating
his Name.
On the whole, esoterism and exoterism have
achieved a healthy balance in Islam.
Part Four: Whither Islam?
For long periods since Muhammad called his
people to God's oneness, Muslims have wandered from the spirit of the
Prophet.
But having thrown off the colonial yoke,
Islam is stirring with some of the vigor of its former youth.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter VII.
Judaism
Part One: Their Passion for Meaning
One-third of our Western civilization bears the
mark of its Jewish ancestry. What lifted the Jews from obscurity to
permanent religious greatness was their passion for meaning.
A. Meaning in God.
From a very early date, possibly from the very
beginning of the biblical record, the Jews were monotheists.
The supreme achievement of Jewish thought was
not in its monotheism as such, but in the character it ascribed to the God
it intuited as One. God is a God of righteousness, whose loving-kindness is
from everlasting to everlasting and whose tender mercies are in all his
works.
B. Meaning in Creation.
Judaism affirms the world's goodness, arriving
at that conclusion through its assumption that God created it. "In the
beginning God created the heavens and the earth" and pronounced it to be
good.
To affirm that existence is God-created is to
affirm its unimpeachable worth.
The Semitically originated religions emerge as
exceptional in insisting that human beings are ineradicably body as well as
spirit and that this coupling is not a liability.
C. Meaning in Human Existence.
The striking feature of the Jewish view of
human nature is that without blinking at its frailty, it went on to
affirm its unspeakable grandeur. We are a blend of dust and divinity.
Human beings, once created, make or break
themselves, forging their own destinies through their decisions.
People are God's beloved children.
The ingredients of the most creatively
meaningful image of human existence that the mind can conceive - grandeur,
sin, freedom, divine parentage; it is difficult to find a flaw in this
assessment.
D Meaning in History.
1. For the Bible, history is neither Hinduism
maya, illusion or a Greek circular process of nature; it is the arena
of God's purposive activity.
2. Second, if contexts are crucial for life, so
is collective action; social action.
3. Third, nothing in history happens
accidentally; God shapes each sequence as a teaching experience for his
people.
4. Finally, all events are important but
not equally important. Each opportunity is unique, but some are decisive.
For India, human destiny lies outside history altogether. Judaism, by
contrast laid the groundwork for social protest. It is in the lands
influenced by the Jewish historical perspective that the chief thrusts for
social betterment have occurred.
E. Meaning in Morality.
Without moral constraints, human relations
would become as snarled as traffic in the Chicago loop if everyone drove at
will. The Jewish formulation of "those wise restraints that make men free"
is contained in her Law. The Hebrew Bible contains no less than 613
commandments that regulate human behavior. Four of these will suffice for
our purposes: the four ethical precepts of the Ten Commandments, for it is
through these that Hebraic morality has had its greatest impact.
Appropriated by Christianity and Islam, four of
the Ten Commandments constitute the moral foundation of most of the
Western world. There are four danger zones in human life that can cause
unlimited trouble if they get out of hand:
1. Force - You can bicker and fight, but
killing within the in-group will not be permitted, for it instigates blood
feuds that shred community. Therefore thou shalt not murder.
2. Wealth - As for possessions, you may make
your pile as large as you please and be shrewd and cunning in enterprise.
One thing, though, you may not do, and that is pilfer directly off someone
else's pile, for this outrages the sense of fair play and builds animosities
that become ungovernable. Therefore thou shalt not steal.
3. Sex - You can be a rounder, flirtatious,
even promiscuous, and though we do not comment such behavior, we will not
get the law after you. But at one point we draw the line: Sexual indulgence
of married persons outside the nuptial bond will not be allowed, for it
rouses passions the community cannot tolerate. Therefore thou shalt not
commit adultery.
4. Speech - You may dissemble and equivocate,
but there is one time when we require that you tell the truth, and nothing
but the truth. If a dispute reaches such proportions as to be brought before
a tribunal, on such occasions the judges must know what happened. If you lie
then, while under oath to tell the truth, the penalty will be severe. Thou
shalt not bear false witness.
F. Meaning in Justice.
It is to a remarkable group of men we call the
prophets more than to any others that Western civilization owes its
convictions (1) that the future of any people depends in large part on the
justice of its social order, and (2) that individuals are responsible
for the social structures of their society as well as for their direct
personal dealings.
Whereas the Pre-Writing Prophets Such as Elijah
and Elisha challenged individuals the Writing Prophets such as Isaiah and
Jeremiah challenged corruptions in the social order and oppressive
institutions.
Thanks to the Prophets, what other nations
would have interpreted as simply a power squeeze, the Jews saw as God's
warning to clean up their national life: establish justice throughout the
land, or be destroyed.
Stated abstractly, the Prophetic Principle can
be put as follows: The prerequisite of political stability is social
justice, for it is in the nature of things that injustice will not endure.
Stated theologically the point reads: God has
high standards. God will not put up forever with exploitation, corruption,
and mediocrity.
One thing is common to all the Jewish prophets:
the conviction that every human being, simply by virtue of his or her
humanity, is a child of God and therefore in possession of rights that even
kings must respect. Wealth and splendor count for nothing compared with
purity, justice, and mercy.
G. Meaning in Suffering.
From the eighth to the sixth centuries B. C.,
during which Israel and Judah tottered before the aggressive power of
Syria, Assyria, Egypt, and Babylon, the prophets found meaning in their
predicament by seeing it as God's way of underscoring the demand for
righteousness.
God was using Israel's enemies against her. The
experience of defeat and exile was teaching the Jews the true worth of
freedom.
Another lesson was that those who remain
faithful in adversity will be vindicated.
Stated abstractly, the deepest meaning the Jews
found in their Exile was the meaning of vicarious suffering: meaning that
enters lives that are willing to endure pain that others might be spared it.
"the Lord has laid on him the iniquity of us all."
H. Meaning in Messianism.
Part Two: The Hallowing of Life. - Jewish
ceremonies and observances
The West, influenced by the
Greek partiality for abstract reason, emphasizes theology and creed, the
East has approached religion through ritual and narrative.
Ritual plays a part in life
that nothing else can fill. In Judaism it aims to hallow life - ideally,
all life.
The name for the right
approach to life and the world is piety. The secret of piety consists in
seeing the entire world as belonging to God and reflecting God's glory.
The Jews preserve this sense
of the sanctity of all things through tradition. Judaism the most
historically minded of all religions finds holiness and history
inseparable.
The basic manual for the
hallowing of life is the Law, the first five books of the Bible.
Part Three: Revelation.
The Jews in their interpretation of the
major areas of human experience arrived at a more profound grasp of
meaning than any of their Mediterranean neighbors; a grasp that in its
essentials has not been surpassed.
The Jew's say they did not reach these
insight on their own. They were revealed to them.
For the Jews God revealed himself first and
foremost in actions - not words but deeds. It was through miracles,
divine intervention.
God took the imitative.
The God that the Exodus disclosed was
powerful and a God of goodness and love. A God who was intensely
concerned with human affairs. It followed that God would want people to
be good as well.
Finally, suffering must carry significance
because it was unthinkable that a God who had miraculously saved his
people would ever abandon them completely. All this took shape for
the Jews around the idea of the covenant.
Yahweh would continue to bless the
Israelites if they, for their part, would honor the laws they had been
given.
Part Four :The Chosen People.
The idea that a universal god decided that
the divine nature should be uniquely and incomparably disclosed to a
single people is among the most difficult notions to take seriously in
the entire study of religion.
The Jews did not see themselves as singled
out for privileges. They were chosen to serve, and to suffer the trials
that service would often exact.
Isaiah's doctrine of vicarious suffering
meant that the Jews were elected to shoulder a suffering that would
otherwise have been distributed more widely.
It is the doctrine that God's doings can
focus like a burning glass on particular times, places, and peoples - in
the interest, to be sure, of intentions that embrace human beings
universally.
Part Five: Israel.
Judaism cannot be reduced to its biblical
period. In 70 A.D. the Romans destroyed the Temple in Jerusalem and the
focus of Judaism shifted to Rabbinic Judaism - from the sacrificial rite
of the Temple to the study of the Torah and its accompanying Oral
Tradition in academies and synagogues around the world.
Today, almost two thousand years later,
there are four great sectors of Judaism that still constitute its
spiritual anatomy - faith, observance, culture, and nation.
The reasons for the establishment of the
modern of Israel in 1948 present complex problems. Without presuming to
answer these problems, we can appreciate the burdens they place on the
conscience of this exceptionally conscientious people.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter VIII. Christianity
Nearly two thousand years of history have brought
an astonishing diversity to this religion. From this dazzling and often
bewildering complex, first will
be indicated the central strands that unite this religion, and then part
two will deal with its three major divisions: Roman Catholicism, Eastern
Orthodoxy, and Protestantism.
Part One: The central strands that unite
this religion
A. The Historical Jesus. - What Jesus said
about himself
1. "The Spirit of the Lord Is Upon Me."
Jesus opened his ministry by quoting
this statement from Isaiah and adding, "Today this scripture has
been fulfilled." We must attend to this Spirit that Jesus
experienced as empowering him, for there can be no understanding of
his life and work if it is omitted.
Not only was Spirit not spatially
removed; though invisible, it could be known.
Often it would take the initiative and
announce itself. It did this supremely to Moses on Mount Sinai, but
it also spoke in a small voice to Elijah, in lions' roars to other
prophets, and in dramatic events like the Exodus.
That Jesus stood in the Jewish
tradition of Spirit-filled mediators is the most important fact for
understanding his historical career.
His immediate predecessor in this
tradition was John the Baptist; and at his initiation / baptism he (John) saw "the heavens opened and the Spirit descending
upon him (Jesus) like a dove."
Having descended, the Spirit "drove"
Jesus into the wilderness where, during forty days of prayer and
fasting, he consolidated the Spirit that had entered him. Having
done so he reentered the world, empowered.
2. "By the Spirit of God I Cast Out
Demons."
The Spirit-filled personages of the
Bible have power, exceptional power, something ordinary mortals
lack. The Gospels attribute these powers to Jesus copiously.
He used the Spirit that coursed through
him not just to heal individuals but, and this was his aspiration,
to heal all humanity, beginning with his own people.
3. "Thy Kingdom Come, on Earth."
Jesus' mission was to crack the shell
of Judaism in which revelation was encased and release that
revelation to a ready and waiting world.
Putting it this way does not cancel the
need for a continuing Jewish presence. Until the world is
regenerated, the witness of a nation of priests remain relevant.
B. The Christ of Faith. - What his
disciples said about Jesus
What they heard him say, and what they
sensed him to be caused his followers to believe they had seen God in
human form.
1. "He Went About Doing Good."
Almost all of his extraordinary
deeds were performed quietly, apart from the crowds, and as a
demonstration of the power of faith.
2. "Never Spoke Man Thus."
The teachings of Jesus have an urgency,
an ardent, vivid quality, an abandon, a complete absence of
second-rate material.
His teachings carry an extravagance
that invited people to see things differently, confident that if
they did so their behavior would change accordingly.
His teachings focused on the two most
important facts about life: God's overwhelming love of humanity, and
the need for people to accept that love and let it flow through them
to others.
Jesus tried to convey God's absolute
love for every single human being.
3. "We Have Seen His Glory."
But what he did and what he said would
not have been enough to edge his disciples toward the conclusion
that he was divine.
It came to the point where they felt
that as they looked at Jesus they were looking at something
resembling God in human form.
C. The End and the Beginning. - The way that
Jesus' earthly ministry ended
He was crucified.
Within a short time his followers were
preaching the gospel of their Risen Lord.
His disciples were convinced of Jesus,
resurrection.
He did not simply resume his former
physical body; resurrection was not resuscitation. It was entry into
another mode of being.
Jesus' followers experienced him in a new
way; as having the qualities of God.
Faith in Jesus' resurrection produced the
Church and its Christology.
This faith extended ultimately to the
status of goodness in the universe, contending that it was all-powerful,
victorious over everything, even death itself.
D. The Good News.
Conventional love is evoked by loveable
qualities in the beloved, but the love people encountered from Christ
embraced sinners and outcasts, Samaritans and enemies. It gave not
prudentially in order to receive, but because giving was its nature.
Once that love of Christ reached the first
Christians it could not be stopped.
Three intolerable burdens had suddenly and
dramatically lifted from their shoulders:
The fear of death
The burden of guilt
The cramping confines of the ego
E. The Mystical Body of Christ.
The disciples went out to possess a world
they believed God had already possessed for them.
Images came to mind to characterize the
intense corporate identity they felt. The first came from Christ
himself: "I am the vine, you are the branches."
Saint Paul adapted Christ's image by using
the human body instead of a vine to symbolize the Church. Christ is the
head; individual Christians are its cells.
In what sense there is salvation apart from
the Body of Christ is a question on which Christians differ.
F. The Mind of the Church.
It was not the disciples' minds that were
first drawn to Jesus; it was their experience.
It was only a matter of time before
Christians felt the need to understand this mystery in order to explain
it to themselves and to others. Christian theology was born, and from
then on the Church was head as well as heart.
Christianity's three most distinctive
tenets are:
1. The Incarnation - In Christ God assumed
a human body, it is affirmed that Christ was God-Man; simultaneously
both fully God and fully man.
2. The Atonement
Its root meaning is reconciliation. Two
metaphors have dominated the Church's understanding of this
occurrence.
a. One, legalistic, runs as follows:
all people sin, sin demands infinite recompense. God made this
payment through the Person of Christ and the debt is canceled.
b. Christendom's presiding metaphor on
this topic has been release from the bondage. The bondage that
imprisons us is ego, an attachment to ourselves, with the fear and
guilt that trail in its wake.
3. The Trinity
This doctrine holds that while God is
fully one, God is also three: God the father, Christ the Son and The
Holy Spirit.
"The Godhead is a Society of three
divine persons, knowing and loving each other so entirely that not
merely can none exist without the others, but in some mysterious way
each is what the other is."
Part Two: The three major divisions of
Christianity
What has gone before is an interpretation of
the points that, substantially at least, Christians hold in common. For roughly
half its history the church remained substantially one institution. Starting in
1054, however, great divisions began to occur. Our concern now is to try to
understand the central perspectives of Christendom's three great branches.
A. Roman Catholicism.
The two most important concepts for the
understanding of this branch of Christendom:
1. The Church as Teaching Authority - The
Church points the way in which we should live.
Ultimately, this idea of the Church as
teaching authority shapes the idea of papal infallibility.
After studying a problem that relates
to faith or morals, he emerges with the Church's answer - on these
rare occasions it is not strictly speaking an answer, it is
the answer and binding on Roman Catholics.
For such occasions the Holy Spirit
protects him from the possibility of error.
2. The Church as Sacramental Agent - The
Church empowers us to live in accordance with its teachings.
Christ called his followers to live
lives far above the average in charity and service. Help, therefore,
is needed and The Church provides it by means of its seven
Sacraments:
a. Baptism
b. Confirmation
c. Holy Matrimony
d. Holy Orders
e. the Sacrament of the Sick (extreme
unction)
f. Reconciliation (confession)
g. the Mass
B. Eastern Orthodoxy.
In most ways the Eastern Orthodox Church
stands close to the Roman Catholic. It honors the same seven Sacraments
On the teaching authority there is some
difference. The Eastern Church has no Pope; it holds that God's truth is
disclosed through "the conscience of the Church."
It stands midway between Roman Catholicism
and Protestantism. Two clearly distinctive features are:
1. Its exceptionally corporate view of
the Church - Each Christian is working out his or her
salvation in conjunction with the rest of the Church, not
individually to save a separate soul.
2. Its mysticism: The Eastern Church
encourages the mystical life more actively. Mysticism is a practical
program even for the laity.
C. Protestantism.
The bulk of its faith and practices it shares
with Catholicism and Orthodoxy but with two great enduring themes:
1. Justification by Faith
When Protestantism says that human
beings are justified - that is, restored to right relations
with the ground of their being, and with their associates - by
faith, it is saying that such restoration requires a movement of the
total self, in mind, will and affections, all three.
It is a mark of the strength of the
ecumenical movement in our time that the Roman Catholic theologians
now increasingly understand faith in the same way.
Faith is a personal phenomenon. No
number of religious observances, no record of good deeds, no roster
of doctrines believed could guarantee that an individual would reach
his or her desired state.
It does not mean that the Creeds or the
Sacraments are unimportant. It means that unless these are
accompanied by the experience of God's love and a returning love for
God, they are insufficient. Similarly with good works.
2. The Protestant Principle
Stated philosophically, it warns
against absolutizing the relative. Stated theologically, it warns
against idolatry.
Human allegiance belongs to God. God,
however is beyond nature and history and cannot be equated with
either or any of his parts. God is infinite.
People, however, continually slip;
first deifying wood and stone idols and later Christians fell to
absolutizing dogmas, the Sacraments, the Church, the Bible, or
personal religious experience.
None of them is God. They point beyond
themselves to God, but let any of them claim absolute or unreserved
allegiance and it becomes diabolical.
God transcends all the limitations and
distortions of finite existence. Therefore, in the Protestant view,
every human claim to absolute truth or finality must be rejected.
This brings the need for continual self-criticism
and reformation to the door of Protestantism itself.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter IX. The Primal Religions
The historical religions span less than four
thousand years as compared with the three million years or so the religions
that preceded them. This mode of religiosity continues in Africa, Australia,
Southeast Asia, the Pacific Islands, Siberia, and among the Indians of North
and South America.
Tribes without depending on writing may have
retained insights and virtues that urbanized, industrial civilizations have
allowed to fall by the wayside.
Part One: The Australian Experience.
God does not evolve; everything that we find
flowering in the historical religions - monotheism, for example - is
prefigure in the primal ones in faint but discernable patterns.
The muted character of distinctions in the
primal religions is nicely illustrated by the religion of the Australian
aborigines.
Aboriginal religion turns not on worship but on
identification, a "participation in," and acting out of, archetypal
paradigms. The entire life of the aborigine, insofar as it rises above
triviality and becomes authentic, is ritual.
Here there are no priests, no congregations, no
mediating officiants, no spectators. There is only the Dreaming and
conformance to it.
Part Two: Features that the Primal Religions
Share
A. Orality,
Place, and Time.
1. Orality - Literacy is unknown to the
primal religions
Exclusive orality protects human
memory.
It increases the capacity to sense the
sacred through nonverbal channels such as virgin nature and sacred
art.
Not being written, information that is
useless and irrelevant is quickly weeded out.
2. Place versus Space - Primal religion is
embedded in place.
No historical religion, not even
Judaism and Shinto, is embedded in place to the extent that tribal
religions are.
The exact and rightful place is a
feature of sanctity.
3. Eternal time
Primal time is a temporal; an eternal
now.
For primal peoples, "past" means
preeminently closer to the originating Source of things.
Closer-to-the-source means to be in some sense better.
B. The Primal World.
Primal peoples are embedded in their world,
starting with their tribe. They are related to their own tribe almost
the way that a biological organ is related to its host's body.
The tribe is embedded in nature.
Even the line between animate and
"inanimate" is broken. Rocks are alive.
Everything is alive; nature extends itself
to enter deeply into them, infusing them in order to be fathomed by
them.
In the primal world there is an absence of
a line separating this world from another world that stands over and
against it. In historical religions this division emerges and much comes
to be made of it.
Primal peoples are oriented to a single
cosmos, which sustains them like a living womb.
The overriding goal of salvation that
dominates the historical religions is virtually absent from Primal
people.
C. The Symbolic Mind.
A common stereotype pegs primal religions
as polytheistic. The issue is not whether tribal peoples explicitly
identify a Supreme Being who coordinates the gods but instead, whether
they sense such a being whether they name and personify it or not. The
evidence suggests that they do.
The most important single feature of living
primal spirituality is its symbolist mentality, a vision that sees the
things of the world as transparent to their divine source.
Mysticism and symbolism are more frequently
utilized among them than among Western Europeans today. Only when we
have fully grasped the mystic and symbolic meaning inherent in most
activities of primitive man can we hope to understand him.
This section should not end without
mentioning a distinctive personality type, the shaman. They are heavily
engaged in healing, and appear to have preternatural powers to foretell
the future and discern lost objects.
Part Three: Conclusion.
Though millions would now like to see the
primal way of life continue, it seems unlikely that it will do so.
There is still time for us to learn some things
from them.
An Outline Review
of
Huston Smith's
The World's Religions
(Our Great Wisdom Traditions)
Chapter X. A Final Examination
What have we gotten out of this inquiry? Has
it done any good? Three answers are suggested:
A. The Relation between Religions.
This book has found nothing that privileges
one tradition above the others, but that could be due to the kind of
book it is: It eschews comparisons in principle. Nothing in the
comparative study of religions requires that they cross the finishing
line of the reader's regard in a dead heat.
There is a second position that holds that
the religions are all basically alike. It is suggested that if we were
to find ourselves with a single religion tomorrow, it is likely that
there would be two the day after.
A third conception of the way the religions
are related says that for God to be heard and understood divine
revelations would have had to be couched in the idioms of its respective
hearers.
B. The Wisdom Traditions. - What wisdom do they
offer the world?
1. Ethics - The Decalogue pretty much tells
the cross-cultural story: we should avoid murder, thieving, lying, and
adultery.
2. Virtues - The wisdom traditions identify
as basically three: humility, charity, and veracity.
3. Vision - The wisdom traditions'
rendering of the ultimate character of things
a. Things are pervaded by a grand
design.
b. Things are better than they seem.
c. Reality is seeped in mystery for
which the human mind has no solution except to be transformed by
flashes of insight into abiding light.
C. Listening.
If one of the wisdom traditions claims us,
we begin by listening to it. We listen not uncritically but we listen
expectantly, knowing that it houses more truth than can be encompassed
in a single lifetime.
But we also listen to the faith of others,
including the secularists. We listen for understanding, understanding
can lead to love. But the reverse is also true, love brings
understanding; the two are reciprocal.
God speaks to us in three places: in
scripture, in our deepest selves, and in the voice of the stranger.
|